“I finished the Columbus Marathon in October in 4 hours and 12 minutes. My goal was under four hours. I missed it.

But the whole point was trying.”

We were built for hard things

For most of recorded history, life was a struggle for survival. If you did not hunt, fish or grow your food, you starved. Farm work was brutal and dangerous. As Dave Ramsey likes to say, a man had to go out of the cave, kill something and drag it home.

That is not our world anymore. Most of us work at a desk, and the work is mostly mental. That can scratch some of the itch to do hard things, but it does not cover the body. We still need to push ourselves physically.

Michael Easter makes this case in The Comfort Crisis (the #3 pick on my list of five books every man should read), a book I have read a couple of times over the last few years. His argument is that chasing comfort leaves us weaker, and that choosing difficulty on purpose is good for us in the long run.1

Find it here (Amazon): https://link.amazon/B0igl0ggz

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

You can see the same thing in real life. Nobody does well when everything is handed to them. Look at how often kids who inherit a fortune end up struggling once the money arrives.

Why I ran a marathon

At age 31, I am not much of a runner. I had not run seriously since high school, but a marathon had always been on my bucket list. I am not the picture of a lifelong athlete, but it could be worse.

So I built a training plan and stuck to it. I exercised every day at some level, with a sub-four-hour goal in mind.

Then I missed it by 12 minutes. For the math people: a 4:12 finish is about a 9:37 mile pace for 26.2 miles. A sub-four finish needs about 9:09. That is roughly 28 seconds faster per mile.

I am not going to pretend that did not sting. But here is what I learned.

The marathon was hard. Showing up every day for months to train was harder, and it was worth more.

The race lasted four hours. The consistency lasted the whole training block, week after week, following the plan when I did not feel like it. That habit of doing hard things over and over is what sticks with you. The finish line is the goal, but the journey is where the change happens.

Finishing under four hours would have been nice, but the really impressive part wasn’t the four-hour race, but the two-month journey of training.

Find your misogi

A marathon may not appeal to you. That is fine. There is probably something that does: something right on the edge of what you think is possible, where you know you would have to work for it.

That is the idea of a misogi, which Easter explores in his book. The concept traces back to Dr. Marcus Elliott, a physician who works with pro sports teams, and Easter popularized it.1 The rules are simple:

  • It has to be extremely hard.
  • You should have about a 50% chance of failing, even if you do everything right.
  • You cannot die.

That middle number matters. If success is guaranteed, it is not really an accomplishment. If failure is guaranteed, it is not a good challenge either. You want the sweet spot, where the outcome is truly uncertain.

“But what if I fail?” Good. Failure has to be on the table. If you are guaranteed to succeed, it probably was not worth doing.

My own misogi list looks like this:

  • A faster marathon. I have a race on the calendar in April. I am chasing sub-four again at age 32. It will be tougher this time because I have to train through the winter, which will make it sweeter if it works.
  • The Knobstone Trail. I live in Indiana, and this is our longest footpath, around 58 miles. I want to finish it in two days.
  • A backyard ultra. In this format you run a 4.17-mile loop every hour, on the hour, until you quit or only one runner is left. Twenty-four loops is 100 miles, and 100 miles is my target.

How often should you do one? I like the idea of one per quarter. If the challenge is bigger, once or twice a year is plenty.

Why it should be physical

Not every hard thing has to involve sweat. But I think the physical part matters, and the research backs that up.

One large analysis of studies on physical activity and death found that adults who got about 150 minutes a week of moderate to vigorous exercise had around a 31% lower risk of dying from any cause than those who were inactive. Half that amount still helped.2 These are observational studies, so they show a link rather than proof. Still, the link is strong and shows up again and again.

There is also research on having something worth striving for. A study of nearly 7,000 adults over 50 found that people with the lowest sense of purpose in life were about 2.4 times more likely to die during the follow-up period than those with the highest.3 Again, that is association, not proof, and illness can lower purpose as well. But it fits what most of us already sense: men who have a challenge in front of them tend to live differently than men who are coasting.

A misogi gives you both. It gives you a reason to train and a goal to point the training at.

If you can, line up your hobbies with your exercise. Everyone should be moving anyway, so if you like hiking, rucking or cycling, you get the fun and the fitness in the same hour. The one exception is the misogi itself. You do not have to enjoy every minute of it. That is sort of the point.

So what should you do?

Pick one thing this week. Do not wait for January 1. Everyone will be making resolutions for 2027, and most will be forgotten by February. If you start today, you are more likely to still be going when the new year arrives.

Make it hard enough that you could fail. Put it on the calendar. Then show up for the training.

What is your misogi? What is something you have always wanted to do, think you can pull off, and honestly might fail?

How I Calculated This

  • The exercise figure comes from a large dose-response meta-analysis of cohort studies (about 31% lower all-cause mortality at 150 minutes per week of moderate to vigorous activity versus inactivity).
  • The purpose figure comes from Alimujiang et al., JAMA Network Open, 2019, using Health and Retirement Study data (hazard ratio of about 2.4 for the lowest versus the highest purpose group, adults over 50).
  • Both are observational, so they show association, not cause and effect.
  • The Knobstone Trail length varies by source. I used the Indiana DNR figure of about 58 miles.
  • This is an illustration, not medical advice. Talk to your doctor before starting a hard training plan.

Sources

Footnotes

  1. Michael Easter, The Comfort Crisis (2021). The misogi rules (extremely hard, about a 50% chance of failure, you can’t die) are credited to Dr. Marcus Elliott. ↩ ↩2

  2. Garcia L. et al., dose-response meta-analysis of physical activity and mortality, British Journal of Sports Medicine (2023). PubMed ↩

  3. Alimujiang A. et al., “Association Between Life Purpose and Mortality Among US Adults Older Than 50 Years,” JAMA Network Open 2019;2(5):e194270. ↩

— Corey Deaton